Skip to main content
Thank you for your patience as we work through our high volume of requests. If you have log in/site issues, please add a screenshot of the errors in your request so we can assist you further.
Help Center Community Shop

BEST steak you ever ate, other than your own...

Comments

39 comments

  • tnranger

    Angelo's Steak Pit, Panama City (haven't been there in many years, so may have changed). We complimented the Chef and he took us back to the kitchen to show us how he cooked them. We went home with a generous supply of his seasoning, and its been my go-to recipe for grilling steaks ever since - even good for venison steaks.

    Texas Roadhouse is my favorite among the chain restaurants.

    0
  • bullshot

    Bern's Steak House in Tampa …………….. without a doubt.

    0
  • pulsarnc

    On a fall motorcycle touring trip to the mountains . Spent the night at a holiday inn in Greensboro nc. It had a bar/ pub / restaurant attached I had a ribeye that was the best steak before or since . That was over 35 years ago and still my standard to judge by .

    0
  • Don McManus

    I like my steak simple. Maybe a little salt before cooking, nothing else. I’ve had steak at Ruth’s Chris, and a couple of very high steak houses, but must confess that the fork soft stuff isn’t for me. I prefer a place like Texas Roadhouse where you get a nice marbled steak you have to cut with a knife and actually chew.

    15
  • Toolman286

    The original Rio Grande Station, just north of Cape May NJ served a blackened ribeye that was still rare in the center.

    0
  • NeoBlackdog

    Spencers at the north end of Kalispell.

    0
  • William81

    When I was a kid I thought the steaks at The Ponderosa were great !!! I have eaten much better ones since then. 🙃

    3
  • TANK78Z

    Linda's La Cantina SteakHouse, in the city of Orlando Florida's outskirts, for a consistently really great, dare I say makes an excellent Ribeye, at a "reasonable" price. better than most high end places here in central Florida that charge a heck of a lot more for almost equivalent quality.

    0
  • Texas1911DE

    …just knock it in the head and wipe its azz and I'm ready to eat…

    6
  • austin20

    Dry aged steak at Bern’s Steak House in Tampa Florida

    3
  • NeoBlackdog
    Texas1911DE: 29941521574939/comments/29941516578843

    …just knock it in the head and wipe its azz and I'm ready to eat…

    Ya gotta at least walk it by the fire first.

    0
  • Ditch-Runner

    I don't recall any one stand out

    Texas road house and tumbleweeds ?

    The Two we vist and like

    But I remember the 1st steak I had I was 18 yrs old

    I Just Met a girl and we double dated with her sister

    We Went to ponderosa when it was popular around 1975 looking back I remember wondering if I had enough money to pay for it as we made plans to go

    At that time i was making 1.65 a hour that did not go very far when dating

    Growing up at my parents house hamburger was as close as it got to a steak

    I've never been to a fancy high-end restraunt for a truly expensive steak and don't see it happening .

    0
  • 4205raymond
    William81: 29941521574939/comments/29941506708507

    When I was a kid I thought the steaks at The Ponderosa were great !!! I have eaten much better ones since then. 🙃

    Use to take the family to Ponderosa years ago in Middletown, NY. The wait line was always at least 50 feet long and out the door. Inexpensive and i thought not so bad. One day we showed up and no line out the front door. Too good to be true. Yep, they had gone out of business. What a shock. Do they still exist????———-Ray

    0
  • KL
    4205raymond: 29941521574939/comments/-1

    https://forums.gunbroker.com/discussion/comment/11438570#Comment_11438570

    Use to take the family to Ponderosa years ago in Middletown, NY. The wait line was always at least 50 feet long and out the door. Inexpensive and i thought not so bad. One day we showed up and no line out the front door. Too good to be true. Yep, they had gone out of business. What a shock. Do they still exist????———-Ray

    They don't. you should have gone more often, Ray. 😁

    6
  • hillbille
    4205raymond: 29941521574939/comments/-1

    https://forums.gunbroker.com/discussion/comment/11438570#Comment_11438570

    Use to take the family to Ponderosa years ago in Middletown, NY. The wait line was always at least 50 feet long and out the door. Inexpensive and i thought not so bad. One day we showed up and no line out the front door. Too good to be true. Yep, they had gone out of business. What a shock. Do they still exist????———-Ray

    we also had a bonanza, just about the same menu, just different name, both are gone now……..

    0
  • 62vld2042

    After the Tulsa Gun Show........we liked to go to Jamil's Lebanese Steakhouse. They cooked a very fine ribeye.

    But for the very best steak dinner..........I'd have to go back a few years, to the anniversary weekend getaway my wife and I had at the Adolphus Hotel in Dallas. In the French Room we had their Chateaubriand for two.........the finest tenderloin I've ever had........not to mention, the entire meal.

    0
  • montanajoe
    • Community moderator

    A local steakhouse Montana Rib and Chop house. The steak is so hot and still sizzling on the plate when they bring it, regardless how cooked.

    Other places from the past. As mentioned, ponderosa, bonanza, outback. Do you remember Flaming Pit? That goes back to my childhood 60's-70's.

    0
  • SW0320

    If it not a ribeye from Texas RH then it is a ribeye from Flemings steakhouse.

    0
  • jimdeere

    The quality of the steak is 90% the cow and 10% the cook.

    9
  • Brookwood

    The best steak I've ever had turned out to be Buffalo! It was served at a VFW Hall.

    0
  • NeoBlackdog
    montanajoe: 29941521574939/comments/-1

    A local steakhouse Montana Rib and Chop house. The steak is so hot and still sizzling on the plate when they bring it, regardless how cooked.

    Other places from the past. As mentioned, ponderosa, bonanza, outback. Do you remember Flaming Pit? That goes back to my childhood 60's-70's.

    I've eaten there and that was also a dang good steak!

    3
  • Horse Plains Drifter
    jimdeere: 29941521574939/comments/-1

    The quality of the steak is 90% the cow and 10% the cook.

    Yes sir!

    0
  • NeoBlackdog
    jimdeere: 29941521574939/comments/-1

    The quality of the steak is 90% the cow and 10% the cook.

    We finish ours (2 Aberdeen angus and a Galloway cow, angus bull) on grass and beer mash. The mash is a waste product for the breweries and they're happy to have us haul it off. Sure makes for a tasty tender steak!

    3
  • ltcdoty

    U.S. Air Base in the UK, 1969. There was a Congressional tour, including the Chow Hall. Low and behold they served us steak…I think it was steak. On one side of mine was an embossed picture of Fess Parker in a coonskin cap…with stitching marks……😮

    6
  • Brookwood

    I can picture ole Andy Devine ordering a couple of those plate size steaks in the movie "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance"

    On the cuff (which meant for FREE) for the town sheriff!😁

    😋

    6
  • bambihunter

    Oddly, it was an Emu steak at a place in S.W. Missouri. It tasted like the best cut of beef you can get, but without the fat. I have looked for them elsewhere ever since with no luck. I know that place was in the path of the Joplin tornado and the buildings were all gone. I can't remember the name of it to see if it is still around there.

    While not the same, when I was in Alaska, I discovered reindeer sausage. I loved that stuff. I ate it nearly every meal while I was there. I want to order a bunch and have it shipped.

    0
  • hoosier

    ST Elmo in Indy. Rib Eye , just a bit over rare. Even 30 years later a I can remember r it. And the Shrimp cocktail was great (on fire sauce).

    Would have cost me a weeks salary. But was a favor owed to a law firm (testimony).

    3
  • Butchdog3

    Mountain Holler in Bakersville, NC. May be a disaster next time.

    I have eaten enough beef to sink a boat over the years and they have been the best I have ever had. They are not a chain store.

    0
  • mike55

    Cattleman's in Oklahoma City. Hands down the best steak I have EVER eaten. About 3 inch thick fillet and you could cut it with a plastic spoon! Very good price too, for the amount of fillet you get. That was 10 years ago, so im sure its doubled in price now(thanks Joe!).

    If you ever within a 100 miles, it would be well worth the trip. The surrounding area is very shady however, so I wouldnt linger if you stray a few blocks.

    3
  • grdad45

    Doe's Eat Place, Little Rock, Arkansas. One steak fed three hungry men. 3 1/2 to 6 pound Sirloin you can cut with a fork, cooked to your specification. $27/lb, but worth it!!!

    0

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity

Didn’t find what you’re looking for?