Skip to main content
Help Center Community Shop

Illegal Aliens To Get Tax Rebates

Comments

33 comments

  • Civil Rights
    all the more reason NOT to vote for McCain or Clinton or Obama.
    0
  • 1911a1-fan
    quote:Originally posted by Civil Rights
    all the more reason NOT to vote for McCain or Clinton or Obama.


    i'm confused, wasn't this bush's plan?
    0
  • Mercury
    Uhh.........if they were assigned a tax ID number......THEY WERE PAYING TAXES!!!!!!!

    Merc
    0
  • Civil Rights
    quote:Originally posted by 1911a1fan
    quote:Originally posted by Civil Rights
    all the more reason NOT to vote for McCain or Clinton or Obama.


    i'm confused, wasn't this bush's plan?


    yes. but he isnt running for re-election. the people who ARE running agree with him and that is why you shouldnt vote for them.
    0
  • TooBig
    as for them paying taxes their still illegal and take the refund and put into the American Taxpayers pot to pay the bill for the Social cost of illegals. Illegal is illegal and it would help pay down the 89 Billion a year social cost WE pay for.
    0
  • Marc1301
    Are any of you truly surprised by this?[xx(]
    I fully expected it.
    0
  • Don McManus
    The term resident alien describes people living in the U.S. legally (see link). An illegal alien cannot be a resident alien. This is not to say that some have not worked the system, but the intent of the package is to exclude illegals.

    http://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc851.html
    0
  • beneteau
    But, thanks to Mr. Bush----he chose not to include "us" that are drawing Social Security. Only the Democrats in the Senate are trying to include us. I voted for that idiot (Bush) twice
    right now---he can kiss my ever loving BUTT!
    0
  • Sav99
    quote:Originally posted by Mercury
    Uhh.........if they were assigned a tax ID number......THEY WERE PAYING TAXES!!!!!!!

    Merc



    How does an illegal alien get a tax I.D. number?
    0
  • kimi
    Fox News just reported that a loophole in the bill allowed for illegals to get the rebates, and that they will attempt to close it come tomorrow.
    0
  • Marc1301
    quote:Originally posted by beneteau
    But, thanks to Mr. Bush----he chose not to include "us" that are drawing Social Security. Only the Democrats in the Senate are trying to include us. I voted for that idiot (Bush) twice
    right now---he can kiss my ever loving BUTT!




    Bummer dude,.......do you think that 40 years of work puts you in front of illegals, or as some like to call them "resident aliens"?

    You are forgetting the brave new world we live in!
    Suck it up,.......they will spend it wisely.
    0
  • fishkiller41
    Have the local gubment hold their money, then notify them that it's waiting for them. When they come in to claim it.KILL THEM!!![:(!]
    0
  • daveald
    Hey guys there is a big difference between resident aliens, and illegal aliens.
    Resident aliens are people who are here legally, and working, or going to school, they have SS number and pay every tax that you pay, they just aren't American yet. When people come to this country they do not become citizens immediatly they go through a natuarlization process, where they learn to become citizens.
    Ilegal aliens, are people who are not paying taxes nor do they have SSn's.
    these people are not going to be getting any money from Uncle Sam.
    0
  • Marc1301
    Dave,.......I understand what a resident alien is!
    Refer to the original post.

    Many that are REAL citizens are being left out of this farce of a welfare payment.

    I would much prefer to see SS recipients that have payed taxes, and been citizens for 40 plus years, get the refund than "resident aliens".

    If a skunk smells like a skunk,.........it most likely is a skunk.
    0
  • dkb2003
    Ok why are you sooo shocked.. Thats ur guys boy aint it..You know Bush. He lets them come here everyday and rob rape and kill our people. He lets them take our jobs..Might as well give them our free hand out too...Dont be shocked thats what you voted for
    0
  • kimi
    quote:Originally posted by dkb2003
    Ok why are you sooo shocked.. Thats ur guys boy aint it..You know Bush. He lets them come here everyday and rob rape and kill our people. He lets them take our jobs..Might as well give them our free hand out too...Dont be shocked thats what you voted for


    Are you inferring that democrats like Obama, Hillary, or Ted Kennedy might be different?
    0
  • Colt Super
    The vortex of America's decline just gets faster and tighter, as we all head for the sewer.

    I'd give my life to help fix it.

    Doug
    0
  • dkb2003
    quote:Originally posted by beneteau
    But, thanks to Mr. Bush----he chose not to include "us" that are drawing Social Security. Only the Democrats in the Senate are trying to include us. I voted for that idiot (Bush) twice
    right now---he can kiss my ever loving BUTT!



    See here is the thing..You voted for him 2 times...???really??? 2 times...hmmm..Its ok i forgive ya..He could give two chits about you...Thats what they do. Repubicans that is...Why do you think they are going to take ur guns..It will never happen..EVER EVER EVER IN THE USA...EVER..Dont compare CANADA TO THE US...IT WILL NEVER AND CAN NEVER HAPPEN....When they said right to bare arms they didnt think that a 15 year old from cally would walk around the streets of L>A with a fully automatic izu and spray a whole block...If they did it would have been writin diff trust me on that....welll...They will never take our arms..
    0
  • kristov
    quote:Originally posted by daveald
    Hey guys there is a big difference between resident aliens, and illegal aliens.



    Not on this web site!
    0
  • NeilTheBrit
    If they have an address to send the check to, get ICE to hand deliver it[;)]
    0
  • zipperzap
    (Don't forget Unidentified Flying Aliens- where do we send THEIR checks?)
    0
  • medic07
    Marc...I understand alot of people have heart burn with the Resident Aliens getting this money.

    Personally I think that those drawing the Social Security should get this as well. Most of those people are on fixed incomes...I know my mom sure is.

    As to the Resident Aliens. I have three of them in my military unit. They have been in the US for greater than 8 years and are working through the system to become citizens. They pay their taxes just as I do...they took the same oath I did...they serve the people of this nation just as I do. They should get the money just as well.

    Now illegals...not only no...but HELL NO. But we all know somehow they will get it too.
    0
  • goldeneagle76
    just got done mentioning this in the other thread about the rebate. It's ridiculous that illegales are getting anything handed ot them!!![:(!]
    0
  • goldeneagle76
    quote:Originally posted by Mercury
    Uhh.........if they were assigned a tax ID number......THEY WERE PAYING TAXES!!!!!!!

    Merc


    but they are still illegal!!!
    0
  • Highball
    Some appear to be supporting this bullsnit.
    All across the USA, there is BILLIONS of dollars being ripped off CITIZENS that run afoul of this or that 'law'...money, cars, houses, land...
    All to rousing cheers from...I expect..the selfsame people supporting this.
    0
  • daveald
    Marc I too worked for years (47) for a good part of that time I worked 2 jobs, I paid all my taxes, was a good citizen.
    Would I like for the federalies to cough over $600. Absolutely! but at this time they have elected to give a rebate to the people who payed taxes "last year". The only question I have for you is that if a person was in this country legally, working and paying taxes, why would you be against there recieving the rebate.
    We have men and women who are legal aliens here who are in the armed forces fighting in our war, if there good enough for that, shouldn't they get the rebate.
    I assume you too are getting SS so I know that you probably could use the money, and would use it for good reasons, as I would. But thats not what the discussion was. You stated that illegal aliens would be getting a rebate, they will not. You cannot be an illegal and resident alien at the same time.
    0
  • Zebra
    disturbed me
    0
  • get_involved
    CLICK HERE http://www.betterimmigration.com/candidates/2006/prez2008.html TO SEE HOW ALL THE PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES STAND ON IMMIGRATION
    0
  • Henry0Reilly
    Do all you people blaming Bush for this think for one second that algore wouldn't have done the same thing?
    0
  • kimi
    quote:Originally posted by daveald
    Marc I too worked for years (47) for a good part of that time I worked 2 jobs, I paid all my taxes, was a good citizen.
    Would I like for the federalies to cough over $600. Absolutely! but at this time they have elected to give a rebate to the people who payed taxes "last year". The only question I have for you is that if a person was in this country legally, working and paying taxes, why would you be against there recieving the rebate.
    We have men and women who are legal aliens here who are in the armed forces fighting in our war, if there good enough for that, shouldn't they get the rebate.
    I assume you too are getting SS so I know that you probably could use the money, and would use it for good reasons, as I would. But thats not what the discussion was. You stated that illegal aliens would be getting a rebate, they will not. You cannot be an illegal and resident alien at the same time.


    WASHINGTON - The $146 billion stimulus package intended to jolt the economy by giving taxpayers rebates up to $1,200 includes cash returns for illegal immigrants who pay taxes.

    Under the plan passed by the House, illegal immigrants who qualify as "resident aliens" and earned a minimum of $3,000 would be eligible for rebates of between $300-$600, FOX News has learned.

    http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,326346,00.html
    0

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity