Skip to main content
Help Center Community Shop

22 mag or 17 hrm

Comments

10 comments

  • intercessor
    I just recieved an e-mail this week from Numrich Arms that they have .17 barrels for Ruger 10/22 Mag. Be interesting to be able to switch.
    0
  • p3skyking
    The distributors that I have talked to are telling me the .17 will probably be a flash in the pan just like it was in the early 70's.

    After people buy into the hype in the gun magazines, buy the weapons and see how easily the round is deflected/affected by wind, dust, etc., it will lose it's appeal.

    I'm sticking with the .22 mag.

    cheap, available, and won't go away.

    What men call a hero...is merely a man who is seen doing what a brave man does as a matter of course.
    A man who is in love with learning is a man who is never without a bride, for there is always more. L'Amour
    0
  • skyman
    I'm interested in some info on this. For a 100-125 yrd varmit round--which is better the 17 or the 22mag. I have a marlin 882ss--pretty happy with it but how does it comapare to a .17

    Thanks
    Skyman
    0
  • tree
    I've been wondering 2?
    any body have a link ? to explain the pros & cons?
    only draw back I can find is I have a bunch of 22 mags and no 17s[^]
    looks interesting?

    T.K.
    0
  • bambihunter
    I had a .17 Rem and when one compares it to other centerfires like it (the .223, 22-250, .220 Swift) it really doesn't fare too well. However, the .17 hmr is really aimed more after the lower end market and is shot from the cheaper rimfire guns (versus the short action centerfire). I too didn't see the benefit of it, but I think it has a nice niche.
    0
  • win62
    hickswr. The trigger can be tuned by a gunsmith. My brother bought a Savage and it had a hard trigger. Gunsmith did a fine job. Smoothed and lightened the trigger. Good luck.
    0
  • string
    I Have both calibers and I love the 17hmr. It is much more accurate than my 22mag.It works great on small game. I am thinking of getting ride of my 22 mag. I have the marlin in stainless,bull. I don't care what anyone says it is very accurate at 100.And that is all you really need anyway.Just my opinion.
    0
  • FrancF
    hickswr
    My 93 had a hard trigger and I put in the Rifle Basix www.riflebasix.com and love it! adjustable from 10oz to 2 lbs
    easy to install. My view worth the 65-70 bucks.

    hsas157x100.gif
    gun1.gif
    Proud Member of
    The Secret Society of
    Black Helicopter Pilots
    0
  • toolman9mm
    well here is my two cents...i have always said that i thought the bullets on the 22 mag rounds were to blunt and cause them not to fly through the air smooth enough to get good b.c. well i have recently purchased the remington 22 mag 33 gr. v-max and what a difference this bullet makes..they are a little pricey but they shoot alot flatter than the hp or sp's and other rounds on the market..i think if they came out with this type of bullet before the 17hmr it would have made a difference..i to once owned a 700 in 17 centerfire and it was a very nice round but it was greatly affected by weather conditions as are other types of ammo but not as much so as the 17's..with that said i have a lot of friends that have bought 17's but i will keep my 22 mags for now and if i need bigger for varmits i'll grab my browning 22-250 or my 700 bdl in 6mm... tom
    0
  • Colt Super
    .17HMR - the answer to a question nobody ask.

    It helps the manufacturers sell more guns and more expensive ammo.

    The 33 grain .22 Mag is the way to go. It will still be around in 5 years.

    God Bless America and...
    NEVER Forget WACO
    NEVER, EVER Forget 911
    0

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity