.357 lightweight vs standard weight revolvers
I'm looking to purchase a .357/38spcl revolver and I'm looking for input about the advantages/disadvantages of the lightweight frames over the standard weight. I'm particularly interested in the Rossi or Taurus 7 or 8 shot ported 4" barrel pistols. It looks like the lightweights are about 1/2 the weight. With porting, how does the recoil differ between the frame styles?
Any other info or opinions appreciated.
Myles
Gunnison, CO
"panic, chaos and mayhem, my work here is done"
Any other info or opinions appreciated.
Myles
Gunnison, CO
"panic, chaos and mayhem, my work here is done"
0
-
Hello 1/2 the weight = twice the recoil 0 -
Myles... Perry shooter hit it in a nutshell. Lighter guns are easier to carry, especially in day to day use, but lighter weight guns are not your friend when it comes to taming recoil.
I would suggest finding a rental gun or a friend who has the model your looking at and trying it out before you buy. Its too much trouble to buy a light weight gun only to find out you dont like the recoil and want to return it, sell it, or worse, not use it.
"Never let school interfere with your education"0 -
I have a S&W 340pd which is a .357 "scandium" revolver. This sucker is EXTREMELY light.
Advantage? When concealed you hardly know it's there!
Disadvantage? Will rip off your arm when you fire it!
I like it alot, and like knowing I have that fire power handy without carring a ton of weight. I practice with .38 and only fire a few .357's to keep sharp should I need it.
It certainly fits a niche in my collection...
Mateomasfeo
"I am what I am!" - Popeye0 -
I sold my wifes Taurus 66 and bought her a Taurus 627 Titanium. Empty the pistol weighs 21 oz. and actually has ALOT less recoil than her full weight revolver did. The porting makes a world of differance. Everyboby that has shot it has agreed that is has LESS recoil than their Pythons, Model 19's and their Model 27's. Try it you'll like it.
Lance
10's RULE
[:D]0 -
Thanks all for the replies.
Yes, I know 1/2 the weight=2x recoil, but I wasn't sure if the porting would change that formula. I guess if both are ported, it doesn't change it. I've not fired a ported .357 so I'm not sure the comparasion between ported and non-ported.
as they say, inquiring minds want to know.
Myles
Gunnison, CO
"panic, chaos and mayhem, my work here is done"0 -
If you try one ear protection is a must.
Lance
10's RULE
[:D]0 -
Zinks caution needs to be underscored I think. With porting a very loud pistol will ROAR. Use ear protection without fail! 0 -
redbiker go with the Taurus 627 Titanium., until you shoot one you will not believe how good a job their porting and rubber ribbed grips do , even with full house loads they are very comfortable to shoot 0 -
Ditto on ear protection.
Heavyiron0 -
Thanks again to all who replied. I always wear ear protection when shooting. Course I should have worn ear protection at all those rock concerts in my younger days too as I am half deaf...
I will look closely at the lightweight Taurus guns. I like the idea of the lighter weight for those few times I do need to carry. Living where I do, it's not necessary most of the time. I've been checking around the net and see that most opinions are that the newish Taurus/Rossi line of guns are right up there in the mid ranks of the top 5 manufacturers. Works for me. Thanks again,0 -
Thanks to one and all for the replies. I'll be looking at the ported lightweight Taurus for my first choice. I've also been scanning the web and find that most of the opinios are that the newish Taurus/Rossi guns are in the mid ranks of the top 5 gun manufacturers. I like the idea of the lightweight for those few times I do want to carry a pistol. Living where I do, that doesn't come up too often. I have 3 semi-autos and want a mid size revolver. I'm probably buying a .44 magnum Ruger from a friend for the big gun.
Thanks again,
Myles
Gunnison, CO
"panic, chaos and mayhem, my work here is done"0 -
I had a S&W 640 5 shot stainless steel revolver. Shooting it was as enjoyable as hitting your hand with a ball peen hammer.
Have fun!
[:D]
Regards,0 -
If you shoot a ported gun at night you will be blinded for the follow-up shot. Remember...Terrorist are attacking Civilians; Not the Government. Protect Yourself!http://www.awbansunset.com/0 -
I don't really know about porting but I was lucky enough to shoot snubbies in .38, .357 and .44spl on the same day.
Taurus .357 and .44, Smith .38 all were either steel or SS.
From that experience I would either stick with the .38 using +P ammo or go with the .44spl if you really need that much Ooomph.
It's hard to explain but the .44spl seemed a lot more "enjoyable" to shoot than the .357
The amount of recoil was about the same but it didn't seem as "sharp" and painfull.
As anybody experienced the same thing or should I just stop drinking?
Daniel.0 -
Red, I own a Ti S&W 5-shot and a Ti Taurus 7 shot. Both in .357 magnum. The S&W kicks like a pissed off mule. The Taurus is ported with the shortest barrell possible. It also has a RIBBER grip. It is a pleasure to shoot for extended periods of time.
BEN0 -
Looks like I will be last before the lock, and I can only support some of the previously stated material.
One of my podnuhs had a Taurus Lightweight in 45LC, ported, soft and full grips. I was surprised... I can't explain it except to say my 44 mags are much more enjoyable with the soft grips. The porting does help, and it is not hard to handle. The comment about flash blindness is very important.... that port will compound the flash blinding at night.. everyone says 'you won't get a good follow-up shot'... hey we all try for the one shot...but not only will you not get a second shot, you won't be able to see where to move too !0
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Comments
16 comments