If you could pick only ONE powder...

jonk

January 11, 2011 18:48

What would it be?

I mean, for EVERYTHING- shotgun, rifle, pistol.

For me there would be one and only one choice. Alliant Red Dot. If you can use Bullseye, you can probably sub Red Dot. Great in shotguns and pistols, and while you'll never realize a full velocity load, fine for reduced plinkers in rifles as well, out to about 1600 fps in a 30-06 cartridge.

0

• 

  Mk 19

  January 11, 2011 19:29

  I don't think I could do that, unless you mean pick only one powder each for:
  410
  28ga
  20ga
  32H&R
  9mm
  38spc
  357mag
  10mm
  44mag
  45acp
  22 k-hornet
  222
  223
  6X45
  6mmppc
  6mmbr
  243 win
  243 AI
  etc.....
  
  I might be able to get away with one powder for each of those....

  0
• 

  meterman

  January 12, 2011 15:49

  700X.

  0
• 

  joshmb1982

  January 12, 2011 17:09

  would that even be possible? rifle powders are to slow for pistols and pistol powders are to fast for rifles no? I know they would work at making noise but what kind of velocity would you get from a 9mm loaded with varget or 4895? or worse yet some of the really slow magnum powders. if you loaded a 12 ga with a pistol powder wouldnt the thing be likely to blow up?

  0
• 

  dcs shooters

  January 12, 2011 18:42

  quote:Originally posted by joshmb1982
  if you loaded a 12 ga with a pistol powder wouldnt the thing be likely to blow up?
  
  
  Most shotgun and pistol powders will interchange [:0]
  I use PB for both [;)]

  0
• 

  sandwarrior

  January 12, 2011 19:29

  I wouldn't hamstring a rifle to allow a shotgun or pistol to work. Therefore, 4895. If I had to reduce a load and add wadding for the shotgun I would do that. Same with the pistol.

  0
• 

  jonk

  January 13, 2011 03:57

  Besides my favorite of Red Dot... FFFG black. That really WILL work in EVERYTHING!

  0
• 

  mbsams

  January 13, 2011 05:47

  UNIQUE

  0
• 

  Mort4570

  January 18, 2011 05:38

  For what I shooot, Unique would be a powder that can do it all for me.12 guage,45 colt cowboy loads,.357 mag.

  0
• 

  cpermd

  January 18, 2011 05:53

  Can NOT be done
  
  CP

  0
• 

  norgexxx

  January 29, 2011 23:55

  If you are talking stockpiling one powder to survive the breakdown of civilization and protect your holdings and loved ones through long stand-offs and seiges and reloading all your brass for the years to come, then you have to match rifles to pistols and shotguns, in other words all straight walled, big bore, cases. Pistols would have to be .41 .44 .45colt or acp, shotguns 20gauge min, prefer 12, and rifles would be 40-65; 38-55(modern)or .375Win 45-70, modren 50-95 or 50-110 or maybe the .50 beowulf or .450 type straight walled cases for some AR platforms and then you could get effective loads in all three types with IMR 4227. This powder functions very well in big bore pistols and rifles and produces passable performance with modestly reduced charges in shotguns, especially with buckshot type loads, marginal with birdshot, but will put pheasent on the table if your skills are good, altho resorting to Black Powder for your birdshot loads would be more conservation effective by saving the smokeless for defensive purposes. Pick your poison. But if this is what you are planning for...choose wisely.

  0

Please sign in to leave a comment.