Skip to main content
Help Center Community Shop

45acp

Comments

7 comments

  • peddler
    Will the extractor leave a mark on the rim of a 45acp shell casing? Just started seeing this with a new Kimber I bought. Was wondering if this is a problem. Thanks
    0
  • Emmett Dunham
    With out knowing the type of weapon could make a difference in the extractor mark. I have gone throug thousands of 45 ACP rounds and most of them have the marks on them.

    Emmett
    0
  • 62fuelie
    The extractor will have a mechanical interface with the outer edge of the case rim when chambering the round and will exert force on the inside of the rim when extracting a fired case. These will usually leave a tool mark on the rim. The ejector will also leave a mark when the case strikes it. Unless these marks are so severe that they cause a concern about the reliability of the case I would go ahead and use them. If you are concerned about the severity of the marks a gunsmith can stone the sharp edges for you.
    0
  • perry shooter
    My opinion is "a cartridge fired in a 1911 type pistol MAY be marked in a number of ways" A as a cartridge is fired pressure increases this expands the case and more or less locks the case to the chamber walls Then as the pressure starts to decrease the slide starts moving to the rear . The extractor Hook is over the rim of the base of the case. Then the other side of the case head slams into the Nose of the Ejector. This causes the case to twist to the right and move out from control of the pistol. At this time it MAY hit the ejection port. SO we can mark the case with the ejector The extractor Or even the ejection port.Military firearms are not designed to allow the case to remain UNMARKED. Rather they are designed to function with very little regard to the condition of the fired case. One can reduce marks by varying the load /polishing both the ejector and ejector as well as opening up/enlarging the ejection port. I have shot 1911 pistols for a number of years reloaded over 300,000 rounds. Some cases have been so many times it is hard to read the HEAD-STAMP and still function and group their bullets within 3" at 50 yards . AS they sometimes say about cars used for competition "CHROME DON"T GET YOU HOME" [;)] Don't worry about some marks only worry if the empty case does not get out of the ejection port. "Praise The Hard-Ball Gun"[^]
    0
  • v35
    What part of the case are you talking about, inside the rim, the rim proper or the rear which can be marked by the ejector, extractor or both?
    A rough chamber will place a heavier load than necessary on the extractor and should be polished. That would account for marks inside the rim.
    Polishing an extractor carelessly can make it unserviceable.
    Hot loads will increase case marking.
    0
  • peddler
    the rim proper
    0
  • v35
    A heavy extractor spring will cause the rough front and sharp edges of an extractor to mark the rim of a semiauto as it forces itself over the rim.
    In addition to lightening the extractor spring on a Kahr TP45 recently, I polished the extractor. The pistol now feeds with much less spring force in chambering.Ejection is unchanged. Cases aren't noticeably disfigured.
    As has been said, rim marking isn't in itself a problem.
    If you screw up the parts, they are cheap enough to replace.
    0

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity

Didn’t find what you’re looking for?