Skip to main content
Help Center Community Shop

Ripped Off??

Nanuq907

Howdy gents, I need your expert eyes please. I recently bought a 1911A1 NM 45ACP that came with one Scoville mag. I decided I'd like to have another mag or two, so I found some online and bought them. They arrived and I'm not sure one is the real thing. I don't want to pay a premium for something that's not as advertised.

Looking them all over, two have the same "grain" to the metal, same finish, same pins at the base and show similar wear from use. These two both lock into the frame securely and pop almost completely out when I hit the release. The 3rd one looks like it's coated with a matte black finish, doesn't have similar wear, but looks to be built and pinned correctly. It only pops out 1" when I hit the release. I tend to think the 3rd one is either a fake or it was sprayed with something black/matte that I could just scrub off with a 3M pad.

So... eagle eyes, are these both genuine Scoville "C-S" mags? They both have the "S" on front of the tongue, I neglected to photograph that. The one on the right came with the gun, the one on the left is questionable.



0

Comments

12 comments

Date Votes
  • Ditch-Runner

    my 2 cents its almost impossible to tell fakes ? copys

    think it was capt Fun one day on here ? may be wrong but I do remember a posted a comment about having two ar-15 rails one brand mane say 200.00 + range and a exact copy about 50.00 or some really low price

    they said in china they do not care so they get a contract to build 1000 or what ever number brand XX RAILS at the end of production run they just keep cranking out copys and sell for way less under some generic name even some times the same brand name .

    one of the short falls of having them make a item for a company they just copy it China as a whole seems to ignore such things

    short story I use to work for a large car ./motorcycle company early on I heard ( maybe just a company rumor but seemed very likely ) in china they the company I worked for set up a plant just to compete and have the real thing on the market as a company in china had copied one of there motorcycles completely even the name plates

    knowing they would face a huge battle with the Chinese government they just started they own plant so the quality of there brand name and product would at least be there . now could I prove it no I doubt a huge corporation would own up to such a thing . this was a internal story passed along

    0
  • Sam06

    No idea but I would get some Wilson combat mags or Chip McCormick mags.

    6
  • chiefr

    I agree, hard to tell, they are marked correctly.

    0
  • Ricci.Wright

    Sam we both know the Wilson and McCormick mags are much better than the old military mags but I think he is trying to just buy vintage military stuff. I assume that is why he bought the old military pistol.

    3
  • nmyers

    But, to answer your question, WW2 contract mags were brush finished, then blued. Your matte mag has been spray painted.

    Neal

    0
  • Nanuq907

    Thanks all, yep you're right, I'm just trying to "complete" the gun with some period correct mags.

    I guess I'll break out the Scotchbrite 3M pad and see what's under that matte finish. If I'm judicious it should clean it up without eating away at it, and give me the smooth eject too.

    Thanks gents!

    0
  • Ricci.Wright

    I have a picture of a caliper. Will that work??

    0
  • BikerBob

    No - you can only use a picture of a caliper to measure pictures not magazines

    9
  • dreher

    Does it make any difference if the magazines are printed on high gloss paper??

    3
  • Butchdog2

    For out house Sears catalogs I like non glossy pages.

    0
  • Nanuq907

    Whadda buncha maroons.


    3
  • Nanuq907

    Yep we got rub marks! Big streaks down the side.

    So is this a POS that needs to go back to the seller?

    0

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity