Skip to main content
Help Center Community Shop

PB&J how do you make it?

Comments

45 comments

  • Frogdog

    No bread. Large white flour tortillas. Extra-crunchy peanut butter and home-made strawberry jam. Double-layered.

    3
  • montanajoe
    • Community moderator

    you got it covered my friend,,,

    3
  • mark christian

    PB on one slice of bread, jelly on the other slice, and then allow the two slices of bread to join forces as a PBJ sandwich.

    9
  • Ricci.Wright

    I had one for lunch. Two slices of oatmeal bread, almond butter and Smucker's Peach Preserves.

    0
  • William81

    Crunchy Peanut butter spread thick on one side of oat nut bread....grape jelly on the other slice....a necessary smooch together and a big glass of milk to top it off......

    0
  • select-fire

    Tons of peanut butter, cut up banana between two white slices.

    3
  • Merlinnv12

    Dave’s Killer bread, 21 grains, butter one side followed by Adam’s crunchy PB, jelly on other side, JAM them together and wolf it down! Mmmmmmm, good!

    0
  • sxsnuf

    Any kind of bread, peanut butter spread thick, as much honey as you can mixed into the peanut butter, my bride's crabapple jelly.

    3
  • Butchdog2

    This is how I eat PBJ. 1 jar peter pan creamy PB, 1 jar fresh strawberry jam. 4 slices very fresh bread, glass ice cold milk.

    One sammich PB and the other slathered with Strawberry jamb. No need to mix two great sammich fixins on one sammich.

    Flush with cow juice, yum yum.

    For a Emerial knock it up a bit try toasting them before eating, delish.

    0
  • diver-rig

    I don't eat pb&j, or drink milk.


    I hope this helps...

    3
  • Ditch-Runner

    peanut butter spread on a cracker ....... then given to my dogs sometimes with there meds 😁

    I never acquired a taste for PBJ sandwiches my departed brother could eat them 24 /7

    question do they still make the PBJ mix in a jar I seem to remember years ago you could buy it pre swirled in a jar at the stores I do not remember its name or who made it


    now as for jelly I am good to go

    0
  • toad67

    You guys don't have a clue about them sammy's. Remember how good peanut butter toast is? Hah, try a toasted PB&J...

    6
  • Smitty500mag

    2 pieces of Sara Lee butter bread with PB on one piece and grape J on the other one. Assemble and repeat as req'd.

    That premixed PB&J is some nasty stuff.

    3
  • Ruger4me

    Pretty much the same as Mark C. said pb on one slice jelly on the other, any kind of bread I have usually honey wheat but whole wheat, white or others will do. As for toasted bread, well I only want the pb on that and it usually is later at night... kinda like now so what the heck it sounds good, later!

    3
  • montanajoe
    • Community moderator
    diver-rig: 30495619913371/comments/30495616410651

    I don't eat pb&j, or drink milk.

    I hope this helps...

    OMG,,Will you be OK?????

    15
  • montanajoe
    • Community moderator

    That premixed PB&J is some nasty stuff.


    Agree +100

    3
  • toad67
    montanajoe: 30495619913371/comments/30495598932507

    That premixed PB&J is some nasty stuff.

    Agree +100

    Who in the heck would ever eat it, or would even make it?? Commies..

    6
  • jimdeere

    I'll have to ask my wife.

    3
  • toad67
    jimdeere: 30495619913371/comments/30495636216347

    I'll have to ask my wife.

    Pardon me, do you happen to have any grey Poupon??

    0
  • William81

    All this talk of PB&J sandwiches led me to make and devour one !

    6
  • Brookwood

    On the subject of PB&J, I recently bought a double jar deal of Welches Grape Jelly from Sam's Club that is so thick that it wrecks the bread when I try to spread it! 😣


    I decided that toasting the bread was my only option to solve this major dilemma, but may try heating said jelly in the microwave before applying to softer bread??


    Going back in time, I remember the brand of that P&J mix in one jar was called "GOOBER JELLY" and it was gross!

    9
  • cbxjeff

    While I haven't had one in about 70 years my grandmother Lachnit made them with jelly on both sides of white bread and peanut butter in the middle. Miss you Bubbie.

    0
  • Bubba Jr.

    I have one at least once a week.

    2 slices of whole wheat bread both buttered

    Thick glob of Jif extra crunchy PB on one slice

    Big glob of Black Rasberry Jam on the other slice

    Low salt potato chips

    Beverage of the day on the side

    MMMMM, MMMMM, GOOD

    Joe

    3
  • Ditch-Runner

    Have to add in my wife likes them or just plain PB sandwiches but she has to share with our husky if a PB jar is open the dog will appear instantly lol

    3
  • forgemonkey

    I didn’t know this ,,,,,,,,

    ‘But beware, some peanut butter brands contain an ingredient called xylitol, which is toxic to dogs and even eating small amounts can be fatal.’

    0
  • BobJudy

    Pretty much any kind of peanut butter + whatever jelly is on hand at the moment but it has to be on a couple of slices of good crusty bread like sourdough. A strange tip that someone gave me years ago is a small sprinkle of salt shaken on the pb side before slapping the two halves together. I was skeptical, but figured that I eat salted peanuts so why not try it. Tried it once and I was hooked. The small amount of salt really makes the taste pop. Kind of a sweet, salty, gooey version of delight. Bob

    0
  • Grasshopper

    Two slices sour dough bread, thick cut, Skippy butter, blackberry or strawberry jam, five slices thick cut bacon, fried crisp, toast bread and add ingredients. Serve with 2% milk or orange juice. A meal.

    3
  • Rocky Raab

    I do love a good PB&J with a glass of milk.

    For my golf course snack, though, I don't want to have sticky jelly issues on my hands. So, I make a PB and American cheese sammie. I do the same when I pack lunch for a day of fishing.

    There seems to be no end of PB and... recipes. Jelly, cheese, banana, bacon, marshmallow, honey, and combinations of the above. All good, really (although I do not like marshmallow anything.)

    0
  • Merlinnv12

    Another favorite of mine is a peanut butter and mayonnaise sandwich on white bread!

    I just learned that my wife has never eaten a PB&J sandwich. I will have to change that.

    0
  • Don McManus

    my understanding is that you start with a track hoe.

    3

Please sign in to leave a comment.

Recent Activity

Didn’t find what you’re looking for?